JAMESTOWN – Several groups will be holding rallies throughout the state today to protest Governor Andrew Cuomo’s NY on Pause executive order.
The order was put in place in March to help slow the spread of the COVID-19 novel coronavirus. But as a result, it’s also forced a spectrum of businesses to close operations while many other have had to make adjustments. Activities and routines also taken for granted – such as socializing, attending church services, children playing on area playgrounds, and group sports have also been put on hold.
Locally, a Reopen New York rally is planned for 3 p.m. Friday at Jamestown’s Dow Park.
Area resident and 2019 Libertarian candidate for County Legislature Gerrit Cain is helping to organize the event. He said in a media release that his group understands and takes the COVID-19 virus seriously, but doesn’t believe that it is prudent, effective, or constitutional to have the government determine which businesses are and are not essential.
“We are concerned with the effects of the PAUSE and its associated shutdowns on livelihoods, mental health, and the overall well being of society at large,” Cain stated. “It is clear to us that there is a wide spectrum of views on how quickly to reopen, what to reopen and how. We believe that with clear information from regional and local health care experts, people should be free to live their lives and do business in a responsible manner. Likewise, we believe that societal and market forces can and will steer behavior and policies toward wise and prudent decisions in terms of the ‘how’ we reopen and restart our lives better than sweeping government mandates.”
Jamestown Police Chief Harry Snellings has said the city is monitoring the situation.
“We’re aware of it. We are working with the state police and they are monitoring social media so we can at least get a feel for what the potential crowd could look like, but for now we’re kind of in a wait-and-see,” Snellings said during the Jamestown City Council’s April 20 work session.
Jamestown Mayor Eddie Sundquist also noted during the same meeting that while a special event permit to hold the rally isn’t necessary, it still could result in a violation of the governor’s executive order, which bans groups of people from meeting.
“There wouldn’t be any [amplified] sound or things like that so a permit wouldn’t be necessary. However, there is an executive order banning all social gatherings. A gathering of individuals of any size up until May 15 is still not permitted under the governor’s executive order. Anyone who violates that can be assessed a fine of up to $1,000,” Sundquist said.
The mayor reiterated his comment about how such an event could be a violation of the governor’s executive order during a Facebook Town Hall Q&A session on Thursday.
But Cain said the group intends for the rally to be a peaceful and respectful demonstration abiding by physical distancing.
“Participants will either remain in their vehicles or walk the sidewalks around Dow Park while maintaining an appropriate distance from one another. We will be carrying signs and likely singing some patriotic songs during the event. At no time do we intend to gather in a concentrated group,” said Cain.
WRFA also recently talked with NY Senator for District 57 and former Chautauqua County Executive George Borrello and asked him his thoughts about these types of rallies taking place in New York State and around the country.
“I would encourage those folks to practice social distancing and to protect themselves, because we don’t know all the details (about COVID-19) and don’t have enough data,” Borrello said. “But I understand the impact and I agree there are serious constitutional questions to what is going on right now.”
Bruce Oakes says
Do you all want to die? How stupid are you people? tRump tells you to do something stupid and you lemmings just follow along.
#ThinTheHerdForNov3rd
#VoteAllDemocrat
WLace says
Your the one who’s stupid living in fear of a virus that has a 98% percent survival rate. Yes check the numbers at worldometer.info and get real time numbers on anything on this planet from deaths and what from as well as real time birth numbers, manufacturing numbers, any other FACTS you would like to know get informed before you speak clown.
Matthew says
Let’s not rally all together. Let’s wait a little longer. Trust me I want to get out there too I want to be able to go into a store without a damn mask on I want to work without having to wear a mask but let’s use our brains here people common sense.
James Olson says
I believe Gov. Cuomo has made it abundantly clear he knows how anxious we all are to get back to our former activities. So I’m not sure, what’s the purpose of a rally that seems to have the primary purpose of expressing a desire to get back to our former activities?
It doesn’t seem Gerrit Cain is aware that “business” exists because government (the collective will of the people) defines it and permits it. All laws pertinent to the sole proprietorship, incorporation, and etc. are established by government. Government establishes the criteria that defines one type of business activity from another. Government regulates how each type of business operates. Therefore, of course, government can define what business types are “essential” to the functions of government and the collective needs of the people.
Gerrit Cain: “…we believe that societal and market forces can and will steer behavior and policies toward wise and prudent decisions in terms of the ‘how’ we reopen and restart our lives better than sweeping government mandates.” Again, Mr. Cain is implying that government isn’t the collective will of the people or that the only time people argue that government isn’t reflective of the collective will of the people is when it’s felt government is being unduly influences by “market forces” (aka business interests).
The history of capitalism amply supports the argument that without restraint and regulation the “market” is willing and able to allow such things as child labour, the 60 hour work week, hazardous working conditions, abject poverty among workers, and etc. which can’t at all be considered “wise and prudent”. So to claim “the market” (business interests) will be “wise and prudent” now is particularly doubtful.